Over the course of the last few weeks, I've happened upon some bad reviews for a few different books I was reading at the time. Some of them, in my eyes at least, came just a hair short of insinuating that the author of this worthless tripe should be beaten about the head and shoulders. As an aspiring author, it's hard not to slip on those shoes.
For most of my life I thought of writing not as a career path but as a hobby. This was partly because I lacked the dedication to see a story through, and partially because I wondered if I could ever deal with the criticism that an author faces by putting themselves-and their art- out there.
You may wonder why I'm thinking about this, as I am nowhere near the publication stage. I feel that for myself, it's important that I not only prepare my manuscript for publication, but that I prepare myself. I don't think of publication as an if, but a when. It may take me five or ten years, but I will get there. Ultimately, getting bad reviews is a good problem to have. It means my book is published, and out there for the world to see. This means that my life's dream has been realized. Go me!
While reader reviews are a long way off for me, beta reader and critique partner reviews are not. No one has read Positive Tension other than yours truly. My husband knows some plot points, but that's it. Just putting my novel into the hands of people I know and love me gives me hives if I think about it too long, so I try not to.
I guess for myself, I had to decide that the knocks along the way to get to publication and then possibly horrid reviews once the book is out are worth it. That doesn't mean I'm feeling very Kumbaya about it, but I've accepted it. I know that I will take some reviews poorly, but I want to be a published author badly enough that it's worth dealing with the negative side. You're putting a part of yourself out there for the world to look at, so like the celebrity that has to deal with the paparazzi following her around, writers have to deal with negative reviews and criticism.
Author Lili St. Crow touched on these topics far more eloquently than I have. You can read her thoughts on judgment & rejection and reviews here.
Writers: How do you deal with criticism?
Friday, August 6, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)













This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAs an author we have a process to toughen us up for the not so favorable review. The process starts with our review of our work after letting it sit, alone for about a month then re-reading it. Then the beta readers and critique partners cut it up. You would want to put snippets of it on www.yalitchat.ning.com or www.absolutewrite.com/forums in the share your work area. If you withstand those places then you are on your rode to tough skin. If the query or sales letter pitching to agents doesn't make you run, then by the time a reviewer comes at you - you'll survive. Now this does come with a warning, the first bad one is the worst. But remember, I can recall one great series of books that I read simply because of a bad review - Harry Potter :-D and I haven't looked at bad reviews the same since.
ReplyDelete*sorry for the removed post above*
Ooohh I usually cry about it and complain to non-writer folk, then I eat a lot of ice cream. So I guess I don't deal with it, I just numb the pain!
ReplyDeleteIt is pretty scary! I also haven't shown my current WIP to anyone. I just don't feel like it is "ready" yet... but I am probably just a wimp.
ReplyDelete@ LM: thanks for your insight and tips! I will be following some of them when I'm ready to share my work.
ReplyDelete@ Candyland: ice cream is a good coping mechanism. I will also keep this in mind. :D
@ Liz: I'm a wimp too, so don't feel bad.